Tuesday, May 21, 2013 • 10:04 AM Comments (79)

Antigone in Boston

posted by Jack Cheng

I was a Creon until I realized that it put me against Antigone. Now I'm not so sure. Last week, listening to public radio, I heard about the protests against the burial of Tamerlan Tsarnaev. I nodded in agreement as various voices denounced the alleged Boston Marathon bomber and felt disgust at the thought that his corpse would pollute our state. Then, an undertaker was interviewed and he did not argue that Tsarnaev deserved any special treatment, but said that we debased our own humanity by denying his body burial rites.

That's when I realized that I was living through Antigone, the classical Greek play by Sophocles and first performed around the time the Parthenon was being built in Athens. As the Academic Director of the Clemente Course in Dorchester, I work to provide college-level instruction in the humanities to a couple dozen low-income adults every year. Antigone is one text that we read regularly, either with our professor of Literature or with our professor of Moral Philosophy.

To review: Antigone's brother had tried to overthrow the ruler of Thebes, Creon. Creon declares that the traitor should not be honored with burial -- and anyone who attempts burial will suffer capital punishment; Antigone disagrees with this edict and disobeys Creon, her fiance’s father. Like any great Greek tragedy, various characters commit suicide and Creon is left feeling miserable.

In class, the students raise and discuss many questions, among them: Is a decent burial really that important? When a moral law is in conflict with a political decree, which should take precedence?

Often the discussion is somewhat abstract, but last week analogies became unnecessary. On Monday night, at the very end of class, I threw out the idea to a few students, “This argument about burying the bomber reminds me of...”

“Antigone!” W finished.

On Wednesday we continued the conversation as a group. Students were already pretty entrenched in their feelings. The continuum ran from M who was totally against burial, through B who thought burial was all right -- but not in the US -- to L who said we should show mercy and let God judge Tsarnaev.

In the middle was W. He had discussed the case with his co-workers and had been thinking a lot about the parallels with Antigone. It sounded like W’s thinking followed my own path.

I was firmly on Creon's side, until I thought more about Antigone. Because when I read the play, I'm incensed with Creon for taking things too far, for wanting the state to act inhumanely to satisfy his own emotional needs. I’m glad Tsarnaev received a burial, because of what it says about our society that we can treat even the hated dead with dignity.

And next year, when we read Antigone, I’ll have more empathy for Creon’s position, even if I still disagree with it.

When people learn about the Clemente Course, they often ask me why our course values the humanities over more "practical" subjects. What relevance does moral philosophy or literature or history have for our students today?

Turns out our students have a leg up on the discussion everyone has been having this past week. Or to put it another way, we study the humanities to review and affirm our common humanity.

Comments (79)
Post a Comment

Thanks, Jack, for showing us how timeless this story is, and how much it has to say to all of us. I've also taught Antigone to Clemente students--in Utah, where the course is called "Venture--and confess to revealing my bias against Creon in class. That bias is usually shared by the class, too, especially since most are women, many of whom have experienced the arbitrary, sometimes cruel, power of men. But in the context of Tamerlane Tsarnaev, this rather odd focus on burial rights (and rites) in the play has new meaning and Creon's resentment is more comprehensible. I would still side with Antigone, but this time, with more understanding of those who don't.

Posted by Jean Cheney on 5.22.13 at 9:43

Thanks, Jean. I agree, the amazing thing about thoughtfully considering a work of literature is that it increases the empathy we have for both real-life and fictional characters.

Posted by Jack Cheng on 5.28.13 at 11:56

Turns out our students have a leg up on the discussion everyone has been having this past week. Or to put it another way, we study the humanities to review and affirm our common humanity.

dentistinroseville.com
Posted by jackman30 on 7.7.14 at 23:47

To review: Antigone's brother had tried to overthrow the ruler of Thebes, Creon. Creon declares that the traitor should not be honored with burial -- and anyone who attempts burial will suffer capital punishment; Antigone disagrees with this edict and disobeys Creon, her fiance’s father. Like any great Greek tragedy, various characters commit suicide and Creon is left feeling miserable.

bed linen in india
Posted by jackman30 on 7.8.14 at 22:55

Antigone's brother had tried to overthrow the ruler of Thebes, Creon. Creon declares that the traitor should not be honored with burial -- and anyone who attempts burial will suffer capital punishment; Antigone disagrees with this edict and disobeys Creon, her fiance’s father. Like any great Greek tragedy, various characters commit suicide and Creon is left feeling miserable.

farby palette
Posted by jhonmarshal1170 on 7.12.14 at 2:28

in the play has new meaning and Creon's resentment is more comprehensible. I would still side with Antigone, but this time, with more understanding of those who don't.

60 second panic solution review
Posted by jackman30 on 8.1.14 at 22:50

last week analogies became unnecessary. On Monday night, at the very end of class, I threw out the idea to a few students, “This argument about burying the bomber reminds me of...”

as others have stated
Posted by danialkhatri04 on 8.2.14 at 8:42

What relevance does moral philosophy or literature or history have for our students today?

antioxidant serum
Posted by jackman30 on 8.11.14 at 23:47

text that we read regularly, either with our professor of Literature or with our professor of Moral Philosophy.

for product preview see rebelmouse.com
Posted by jackman30 on 8.15.14 at 3:44

Thanks, Jean. I agree, the amazing thing about thoughtfully considering a work of literature is that it increases the empathy we have for both real-life and fictional characters.

your-accountingservices.com

Posted by jason049 on 8.17.14 at 5:29

it increases the empathy we have for both real-life and fictional characters.


buy instagram likes

Posted by jason049 on 8.18.14 at 0:10

You've posted so much good stuff in the past, and you are posting some amazing stuff in the present as well. Cheap Price blog comments

Posted by jason049 on 8.18.14 at 23:55

last week analogies became unnecessary. On Monday night, at the very end of class, I threw out the idea to a few students, “This argument about burying the bomber reminds me of...”

www.losethebackpain.org.uk

Posted by jason049 on 8.23.14 at 2:40

last week analogies became unnecessary. On Monday night, at the very end of class, I threw out the idea to a few students, “This argument about burying the bomber reminds me of...”..

Texas Workforce Commission Login
Posted by micheljhon on 8.23.14 at 3:36

've posted so much good stuff in the past, and you are posting some amazing stuff in the present as well...

blog commenting services cheap
Posted by micheljhon on 8.25.14 at 5:05

I like the part where you say you are doing this to give back but I would assume by all the comments that this is working for you as well. SEO work

Posted by jason049 on 9.1.14 at 6:14

Really well composed article this is. One of the best written articles that I've ever read list surely includes this article. This is just brilliant! Keep it up! bible and religion

Posted by aqibarif74123 on 9.1.14 at 17:38

One of the best written articles that I've ever read list surely includes this article. This is just brilliant! Keep it up!

how to get the best price
Posted by jason049 on 9.1.14 at 23:48

e posted so much good stuff in the past, and you are posting some amazing stuff in the present as well..

window tint perth
Posted by micheljhon on 9.2.14 at 3:28

I feel really happy to have seen your webpage and look forward to so many more entertaining times reading here. Thanks once more for all the details https://archive.org/details/girlfriend-activation-system-review

Posted by jason049 on 9.2.14 at 3:37

sted so much good stuff in the past, and you are posting some amazing stuff in the present as well....

Keyword
Posted by micheljhon on 9.2.14 at 6:55

sted so much good stuff in the past, and you are posting some amazing stuff in the present as well......

Whiteboard
Posted by micheljhon on 9.2.14 at 6:59

webpage and look forward to so many more entertaining times reading here. Thanks once more for all the detail..

Whiteboard
Posted by micheljhon on 9.2.14 at 7:02

Hey there thanks for showing me this. I must say that your blogpost was the most enjoying read I've seen in a long time. Greetings from Home warranty Houston home warranty companies texas

Posted by Prashant on 9.2.14 at 22:23

howing me this. I must say that your blogpost was the most enjoying read I've seen in a long time. Greetings from..

Whiteboard
Posted by micheljhon on 9.2.14 at 23:32

i also have you saved to fav to look at new information in your site https://www.rebelmouse.com/reversemydiseasetodayreviews/

rebelmouse
Posted by jason049 on 9.3.14 at 0:02

i also have you saved to fav to look at new information in your site

seo free analysis
Posted by jason049 on 9.3.14 at 1:06

When a moral law is in conflict with a political decree, which should take precedence. Wedding Cufflinks

Posted by laluprasah on 9.3.14 at 7:10
The internet is bogged down with bogus blogs with no real message but the post was fantastic and well worth the read.Thank you for sharing this with me. seo service
Posted by bertgrays on 9.5.14 at 23:32
The internet is bogged down with bogus blogs with no real message
but the post was fantastic and well worth the read.Thank you for sharing
this with me. seo service
Posted by bertgrays on 9.5.14 at 23:33

But wait- If they get rid of abject failures they'll have to disband their current stable of commenters. Low price good backlinks service

Posted by jason049 on 9.6.14 at 1:15

But wait- If they get rid of abject failures they'll have to disband their current stable of commenters... alicia pennington

Posted by jason049 on 9.6.14 at 4:15

Antigone is one text that we read regularly, either with our professor of Literature or with our professor of Moral Philosophy.

real estate websites for agents
Posted by danialkhatri04 on 9.6.14 at 6:47

thank you, the information presented on this website really helped me in understanding the development of the world, especially in the medical field obat diabetes obat kolesterol

Posted by obat diabetes on 9.7.14 at 4:40

As the sun sets students can embark on a tour of Brighton's gay village with exclusive drinks deals before returning to Brighton Dome Corn Exchange for a club night
pregnancy miracle method

Posted by jason049 on 9.7.14 at 4:42

I’m glad Tsarnaev received a burial, because of what it says about our society that we can treat even the hated dead with dignity.

fotoperiodismo de boda en barcelona
Posted by danialkhatri04 on 9.8.14 at 22:35

Analysis is based on a classical life-cycle model of savings and investment decisions, augmented with a salience cost over participation in Individual Savings Accounts (ISAs)..

mike fiore's text the romance back 2.0 examples
Posted by danialkhatri04 on 9.8.14 at 23:46

savings and investment decisions, augmented with a salience cost over participation in Individual Savings Accounts (ISAs)../....

ww2 helmets for sale
Posted by blackrose111 on 9.9.14 at 2:07

-cycle model of savings and investment decisions, augmented with a salience cost over participation in Individual Savings Accounts....

US Waiver
Posted by blackrose111 on 9.9.14 at 3:21

investment decisions, augmented with a salience cost over participation in Individual Savings Accounts......

red book standard
Posted by blackrose111 on 9.9.14 at 3:54

augmented with a salience cost over participation in Individual Savings Accounts.....

aemaesg.ca
Posted by blackrose111 on 9.9.14 at 4:13

with a salience cost over participation in Individual Savings Accounts.........

cho thue can ho thao dien
Posted by blackrose111 on 9.9.14 at 4:33

r participation in Individual Savings Accounts............

creativecommons.org
Posted by blackrose111 on 9.9.14 at 4:58

Antigone is one text that we read regularly, either with our professor of Literature or with our professor of Moral Philosophy... https://www.rebelmouse.com/thegirlfriendactivationsystem

Posted by danialkhatri04 on 9.9.14 at 23:16

Tsarnaev received a burial, because of what it says about our society that we can treat even the hated dead with dignity. Advanced Dermatology

Posted by john17nider on 9.10.14 at 3:17

I couldn't find any knowledge on this matter prior to.Also operate a site and if you are ever interested in doing some oz naturals vitamin c serum


Posted by jason049 on 9.10.14 at 4:44

I have read some good stuff here. Certainly price bookmarking for revisiting. I surprise how much attempt you place to make any such fantastic informative website.www.PetHealthExperts.com/


Posted by jason049 on 9.10.14 at 6:01

bookmarking for revisiting. I surprise how much attempt you place to make any such fantastic informative website..........

www.facebook.com/
Posted by blackrose111 on 9.11.14 at 3:19

Hello, i read your blog occasionally and i own a similar one and i was just wondering if you get a lot of spam remarks? If so how do you stop it, any plugin or anything you can advise? I get so much lately it’s driving me insane so any assistance is very much appreciated. Veterans Flag

Posted by netrales on 9.13.14 at 6:02

you can advise? I get so much lately it’s driving me insane so any assistance is very much appreciated.....

Production Blog
Posted by blackrose111 on 9.13.14 at 23:19

I get so much lately it’s driving me insane so any assistance is very much appreciated.......

Production Blog
Posted by blackrose111 on 9.13.14 at 23:31

Antigone is one text that we read regularly, either with our professor of Literature or with our professor of Moral Philosophy. Carol's Potty Training In 3 Days was a big help

Posted by danialkhatri04 on 9.13.14 at 23:46

read regularly, either with our professor of Literature or with our professor of Moral Philosophy....

BoostMyTest.com
Posted by blackrose111 on 9.14.14 at 0:09

I get so much lately it’s driving me insane so any assistance is very much appreciated..........

vitamina d
Posted by blackrose111 on 9.14.14 at 2:12

I get so much lately it’s driving me insane so any assistance is very much appreciated...

for more
Posted by blackrose111 on 9.14.14 at 2:37

driving me insane so any assistance is very much appreciated.......

kickstartmyads
Posted by blackrose111 on 9.14.14 at 3:15

so any assistance is very much appreciated........

FIFA 15
Posted by blackrose111 on 9.14.14 at 4:03

driving me insane so any assistance is very much appreciated.....

Flat Fee Realty
Posted by blackrose111 on 9.15.14 at 3:25
it's good <a href="http://www.canhotanphuoc.biz/" title="can ho tan phuoc" target="_blank" rel="dofollow"><strong>can ho tan phuoc</strong></a>
Posted by can ho tan phuoc on 9.15.14 at 20:13

You can not take the risk to 100% of the deposit <a href="http://www.canhotanphuoc.biz/" title="can ho tan phuoc" target="_blank" rel="dofollow"><strong>can ho tan phuoc</strong></a>

Posted by can ho tan phuoc on 9.15.14 at 20:20

Paris apartments tan phuoc between Saigon <ahref="http://www.canhotanphuoc.biz/" title="can ho tan phuoc" target="_blank" rel="dofollow"><strong>can ho tan phuoc</strong></a>

Posted by can ho tan phuoc on 9.15.14 at 23:42

The offers a sampling of some standard available models. In addition, custom designs are available upon request. https://rebelmouse.com/m3systemmichaelgriswold/

Posted by danialkhatri04 on 9.15.14 at 23:58

sampling of some standard available models. In addition, custom designs are available upon request...

best argan oil wordpress
Posted by blackrose111 on 9.16.14 at 2:09

Bereich und eine hohe Auflösung der Sensoren stellen den Einsatz für unterschiedlich große Patienten sicher. Moderne Flusssensoren messen Flussmengen bis zu 250 Liter pro Minute und erfassen Mengen unter einem Liter noch mit hoher Genauigkeit. https://rebelmouse.com/morethanjustfriendsreviews/

Posted by danialkhatri04 on 9.16.14 at 4:48

Vocational school specializing in training VAAC cookery courses <a href="http://xn--dynun-uwa4814c8a.com/" title="day nau an" target="_blank" rel="dofollow"><strong>day nau an</strong></a>

Posted by day nau an on 9.17.14 at 0:22

<a href="http://xn--dynun-uwa4814c8a.com/" title="day nau an" target="_blank" rel="dofollow"><strong>day nau an</strong></a>

Posted by day nau an on 9.17.14 at 0:23

text that we read regularly, either with our professor of Literature or with our professor of Moral Philosophy. loft conversion design ideas

leave hundreds of thousands with a sense of abandonment,’ Barjot added. ‘But we do not want to have a climate of violence. If our freedom of speech on the podium is not met, we will not stay.’ - See more at: http://www.gaystarnews.com/article/france%E2%80%99s-anti-gay-leader-will-not-attend-marriage-protest240513#sthash.IUWedWJI.dpuf
leave hundreds of thousands with a sense of abandonment,’ Barjot added. ‘But we do not want to have a climate of violence. If our freedom of speech on the podium is not met, we will not stay.’ - See more at: http://www.gaystarnews.com/article/france%E2%80%99s-anti-gay-leader-will-not-attend-marriage-protest240513#sthash.IUWedWJI.dpuf
Posted by danialkhatri04 on 9.17.14 at 0:39

Paris apartments tan phuoc between Saigon

Posted by can ho tan phuoc on 9.17.14 at 1:48

Vocational school specializing in training VAAC cookery courses, training specialist cookery senior

Posted by day nau an on 9.17.14 at 1:52

Frequent visits here are the best way to thank you for your effort, which is the objective why I'm going to the web page everyday, looking for new, exciting details. Many, many thanks! <a href="http://businessideas.pixnet.net/">click here</a>

Posted by chestertheus on 9.17.14 at 5:09

thank you for your effort, which is the objective why I'm going to the web page everyday, looking for new, exciting details.......

cialis 20 mg
Posted by blackrose111 on 9.17.14 at 22:47

The continuum ran from M who was totally against burial, through B who thought burial was all right -- but not in the US -- to L who said we should show mercy and let God judge Tsarnaev.

buy likes
Posted by jackman30 on 9.17.14 at 23:35

but not in the US -- to L who said we should show mercy and let God judge Tsarnaev....

chat rooms online
Posted by blackrose111 on 9.18.14 at 0:11

but not in the US -- to L who said we should show mercy and let God judge....

igm online loans
Posted by blackrose111 on 9.18.14 at 0:46

disobeys Creon, her fiance’s father. Like any great Greek tragedy, various characters commit suicide and Creon is left feeling miserable.

thegentlife.com/
Posted by jackman30 on 9.18.14 at 4:25

I work to provide college-level instruction in the humanities to a couple dozen low-income adults every year. Antigone is one text that we read regularly, either with our professor of Literature or with our professor of Moral Philosophy. Rubbish removal London

Posted by danialkhatri04 on 9.18.14 at 5:30

Antigone is one text that we read regularly, either with our professor of Literature or with our professor of Moral Philosophy. iPhone 6

Posted by danialkhatri04 on 9.18.14 at 11:04

abstract, but last week analogies became unnecessary. On Monday night, at the very end of class, I threw out the idea to a few students, “This argument about burying the bomber reminds me of...” Air tightness testing

Posted by danialkhatri04 on 9.18.14 at 14:21

Tan Phuoc apartment style aristocratic elegance of Paris in the heart of Saigon

Posted by can ho tan phuoc on 9.18.14 at 19:37
Comment:

Name:

Password:

New User/Guest?

Find it Here:
keyword:
search type:
search in:

« Previous   |   Next »
« Most Recent Post
« Permalink
Print Email RSS feed

Photo Galleries
Archives
MAY 2013
S M T W T F S
      1 2 3 4
5 6 7 8 9 10 11
12 13 14 15 16 17 18
19 20 21 22 23 24 25
26 27 28 29 30 31  
Antigone in Boston
At the Table
Links
Copyright © 2014 by The Valley Advocate.