Monday, September 10, 2012 • 10:21 AM Comments (33)

Humanities and Economic Development

posted by Kip Bergstrom

These remarks were first presented on July 17, 2012 at a regional forum on the humanities and civic life organized by the American Academy of Arts and Sciences and the six New England state humanities council.

* * * *

The most important role of the humanities in economic development is in its contribution to the preservation and enrichment of what the National Trust calls “places that matter”—places that people care about.

In the throes of a jobless recovery from the Great Recession, it is fashionable to think that economic development is all about jobs. It is not. It is at least equally about making great places. Or to put it another way, I believe that our most important work as a species is to create places that matter, and that economic development can contribute to that mission, or detract from it, depending on how it’s done. Too many places have sold their soul chasing economic growth, and are now realizing how hard it can be to use some of their prosperity to buy back some soul.

The first and most revolutionary thing we ever did as a species was 40,000 years ago, when our ancestors created the first public art, using their hands as stencils, blowing pigment onto the cave wall around them, showing through that first act that our brains are capable of symbolic, conceptual thinking, uniquely among all species.

The whales and the dolphins have a form of language, but only we have art and science, and the symbolic and conceptual thinking that makes it possible. And in an unbroken chain from that first cave painting to today, it is the same brain that made that first cave art that could conceive of, build a machine to detect, and then discover the Higgs boson particle. From crude cave painting to a new understanding of the universe and its origins there is one brain with its unique capacity for pattern recognition and conceptual thinking, one unified creative process that is the same for the best of our art and science. Truly, then, we are art.

Those first cave drawings, crude as they were, nonetheless transformed a hunk of rock into a place of meaning. The drawings proclaim: “We are here. This is our place.”

In 40,000 years of practice, we’ve gotten much better at public art, but art still has much of that magic of its first application, the ability to transform something dark and scary into something safe, inviting and vibrant…and more quickly and cheaply than any other thing we can do.

I believe strongly in this proposition:

Great art makes great places. Great places attract great talent. Great talent creates great jobs.

It is based on the idea that mobile, young talent, the life blood of innovative companies, like to live in cool places, and that art is one of the cheapest and fastest ways to create cool places. This role of art in placemaking has much more potential economic impact than the direct economic impact of spending by arts organizations and their patrons. The same is true of historic preservation: the economic impact of historic preservation in placemaking is more significant than the direct economic impact in construction jobs and increased property tax revenues.

I believe that if we prove this connection to placemaking and talent recruitment, we can increase state and federal funding for arts and historic preservation.

Historic preservation has three roles in placemaking. The first is that great historic buildings are great art. Architecture is an art form that adds beauty to our lives and that adds texture, character and distinctiveness to our places. Not all old buildings are works of art, but many of them are, and they are worthy of preservation for that reason and because they make the places we live and work, places that matter.

It is also true that great history makes great places. Historic buildings have another dimension that goes beyond the aesthetic: they are vessels of meaning. They have a story. They remind us of who we are, where we’ve been, and by giving us that perspective, help us to see where we’re going, who we might become. History provides contexts that give our lives meaning and continuity and help us understand the environments we live in. Some buildings become the vessels for the creation of new stories in their adaptive reuse. Some have such important stories that we do not allow them to be recycled as offices or housing, but preserve them as public spaces. But these too continue to be the crucibles of our reinvention, as the power of the original story inspires the creation of new ones.

Our best buildings both carry stories and make stories, in ways that are deeply personal. The Greeks called this Civitas—a collective pride of place that comes of a sharing of stories, past and present. This idea of Civitas, of lived-in and living history, is something that we on the east coast have more of than other places in the country. I grew up in the West, where history is like a rare butterfly pinned to a mounting board under glass. You can look at it, but not touch it. It blew my mind when I first moved here that you could sleep in history, work in history, eat in history, hold your most significant public and private events in history. Our ancestors and their stories are always with us here, and those stories help to guide us forward. We are, in a larger sense, the stewards of nation’s stories, our legacy to preserve. In the West, the critical legacy is wilderness, landscapes untouched by people and buildings. Those landscapes inspire us too, giving our nation its sense of possibility. That is the West’s legacy to preserve. Ours is history.

In telling that history, it is important not to just to tell the stories of the folks who did the best job of keeping their objects. In New England, our history is not primarily that of the Puritans and their descendants, though you might not guess that based on the number of their homes we have preserved. The Connecticut state motto, “Qui Transtulit Sustinet,” translated into modern English means “Where the Immigrant Prospers.” For over 350 years, immigrants have prospered here, and still do. Their stories are can be found in many places, but especially in the mill buildings of the 19th century and in ethnic urban neighborhoods, towns and villages that still thrive today.

Many of our cities have a higher percentage of foreign born today than they did in the early 1900’s at the peak of industrialization and European immigration. They are a diverse lot, this latest wave of immigrants, hailing from Latin America, Europe, Asia and Africa, with a broad range of educational experience. In fact, the influx of college-educated foreign-born young people more than offsets the outflow of American-born college-educated young people, such that New England actually has a brain gain going on, courtesy of immigrants.

State humanities councils, historical societies, and cultural organizations all over New England have valued immigrant experiences—current and historical—and recognize that the stories of diverse people create our heritage. Our built environment with its rich stock of colonial and nineteenth century architecture has also been the traditional hallmark of these values and what makes New England locales “places that matter.”

It’s easy to get carried away with heritage architecture and historic preservation precisely because buildings are vessels of meaning. But they are also just buildings. In fact, sometimes, old buildings are more important for the fact that they are old, than that they are meaningful. When Jane Jacobs, the great urbanist, said the four key physical ingredients to great neighborhoods are density, mixed use, short blocks and old buildings, and when she said that new ideas come from old buildings, she was not talking about heritage architecture. In both instances, what she was talking about was cheap space. When you redevelop an old building, you often make it into a new building from a rent perspective. This narrows the range of uses that can afford to be in the building, in particular the income/ethnic mix of people, the mix of retail and the mix of commercial. This is why gentrification leads so often its own demise, making distinctively funky places into homogeneous, upscale, generic-chic places. While mixed use and even mixed income may fly in the face of years of misguided zoning policy and cultural tendencies, it is exactly the formula that produces sustainable, dynamic and GROWING economies. It's important to keep a significant portion of the old buildings in a place undeveloped and accessible for low-budget uses, and to build affordable housing and affordable retail and commercial space into redevelopment projects (including through the use of historic preservation tax credits), if you want to preserve diversity and distinctiveness.

The ultimate challenge of the humanities is to energize a network of public and private capabilities to create places that are not cookie-cutter subdivisions, strip malls and office parks—the generic, default development pattern of most of the suburban American landscape—but rather places that are “whole” and “authentic”…that is, places that are: full of life; diverse and distinctive in their built form, natural environment and social networks; empowering of their people; transit and digitally connected; water and energy efficient; and disaster resilient.

We need to use historic preservation to deliberately sustain and expand diversity—of people, buildings, uses, businesses, habitats and species—in the face of prevailing economic forces that tend to diminish diversity…in other words, we need to prove, despite overwhelming evidence to the contrary, that a community can be economically successful without losing its soul. Our mission is to bring beauty to our places, to preserve and constantly renew their stories and to sustain and enhance the diversity that makes us whole. There is no higher calling than that, nor any that is more important to our economy and our culture.

Comments (33)
Post a Comment

Thanks for such an interesting article here. I was searching for something like that for quite a long time and at last I have found it here. ?????? ?????? ????????? ?????? ????????? ??????

Posted by Maddaysingh098 on 7.11.14 at 3:07

I love listening to rock and enjoy in very much.I just want you to know That this blog really gonna help me to broaden my knowledge.Thanks how to be rich

Posted by Maddaysingh098 on 7.11.14 at 3:08

Corpus Christi Personals Corpus Christi TX Singles We have men and women seeking several different relationship types. Our Local Corpus Christi TX men and women are here for dating, personals,long term relationships, friendship, romance and some are here to start a compatible relationship and find a soul mate and life partner Corpus Christi Personals We offer advanced search and simple city search as well. This will allow someone interested in Dating to do a simple browse from profile to profile and city to city. For more info, visit my site ! Hampton bay lighting and fan company site, ceiling fans and furniture. For more info, visit my website ...

Posted by khare on 8.3.14 at 4:30

Cash Out Refinance ! Cashing out refers to the refinancing of a loan where the borrowers will borrow money on their own home. If a home is appraised at $100,000 and the borrower's outstanding mortgage loan is $60,000, it is possible to enter into an 80% cash-out refinance transaction for a loan of $80,000 (80% of $100,000). The new mortgage of $80,000 will pay off the $60,000 loan and leave $20,000 cash-out to the borrowers. What are the benefits? By cashing out on your home, you can obtain cash on the value of your own home to pay off debts or upcoming expenses. The refinance transaction can also provide you with a better mortgage loan interest rate that will save on your monthly mortgage payments during the loan. And it's tax-deductible. Please visit site ...

Posted by khare on 8.10.14 at 23:44

Look at Goodwill stores for used furniture. You may be surprised at the quality of furniture that you'll find at Goodwill. They typically don't accept furniture with any sort of tears or stains, so the overall quality is pretty good. And the prices are much less than what you'll see buying new. start potty training program reviews

Posted by casusbubble on 9.6.14 at 6:53 The Tao Of Badass: Joshua Pellicer Reveals His Weirdly Effective Science-Backed Attraction System That Takes You From "Loveable Loser" To Total Badass With Women In No Time Flat... Written for consumers by a consumer, this fan site includes a fun and informative Tao Of Badass review, ebook FAQ, and PDF download guide that provides an insider's look at the program and answers frequently asked questions about Josh Pellicer's unique and highly popular attraction guide. Please visit site ...

Posted by khare on 9.7.14 at 5:06

Definitely appreciate people revealing this specific post. Definitely appreciate it! Wish far more. obat herbal asam urat

Posted by obat herbal asam urat on 9.7.14 at 5:32

At most, you need to complete between twenty-five and fifty reps for each body part, roughly two or three times a week to gain the most muscle mass. This is going to be very beneficial to serious lifters. If you strive to do more than this, you may be wasting your time because overdoing it can lessen the results that you see. somanabolic muscle maximizer

Posted by casusbubble on 9.7.14 at 9:36

anycarlocksmith Any Car Locksmith guarantees customer satisfaction for all of your automobile locksmith needs. Mobile and ready when you require it, our roadside and in-store service and support capably handles any locksmith emergency, reproduction, installment function or repair. please visit site ...

is female vaginal ejaculation real That “squirting” and “gushing” are the same thing as female ejaculation. Squirting and gushing are often used interchangeably when talking about female ejaculation, but they’re actually a different thing. Female ejaculation with all its amazing (including. healing!) powers and incredible sensations has been successfully kept away from both women and men. Please visit my website ...

Posted by khare on 9.10.14 at 4:56

It has been simply extremely generous with you to provide openly what exactly many individuals would’ve marketed for an e-book to end up making some cash for their own end, primarily given that you could have tried it in the event you wanted. Desain Rumah Tingkat Fungsional

Posted by selmoner on 9.15.14 at 4:09

I request that you will return to the Academy my most sincere thanks for this honour” —Charles Darwin, 1874. denise milani wallpaper

Posted by richardstom38 on 9.16.14 at 2:57

Low Down Loan The Federal Housing Administration (FHA) - which is part of HUD - insures the loan, so your lender can offer you a better deal. FHA allows a buyer to purchase a home with as little as 3.5% down. They tend to be more lenient on areas such as credit, funds to close and co-borrowers. please click here site ... The Black Belt Blueprint: Nicolas Gregoriades Reveals His Cutting-Edge, Step-By-Step System For Mastering Brazilian Jiu Jitsu Techniques And Becoming A BJJ Black Belt In Record Time... Written for consumers by a consumer, this fan site includes a fun and informative Black Belt Blueprint review, ebook FAQ, and PDF download guide that provides an insider's look at the program and answers frequently asked questions about Nicolas Gregoriades' unique and highly popular jiu jitsu guide. Please visit site ...

Posted by khare on 9.16.14 at 22:11

Thank you for the excellent content I did experienced studying it, I will be sure to save your website and definitely will come returning from again. I want to motivate that you proceed your excellent job, have a excellent day. Great Deals

Posted by deals on 9.18.14 at 8:17

I discovered something amazing in your article really remarkable in fact. I seriously enjoyed reading it and you simply make quite some great points. I am surely gonna bookmark this web-site for that foreseeable future! Really wonderful blog! Thanks mate.

Posted by deals on 9.18.14 at 8:21

a text to get your ex back This Text Your Ex Back review examines the Michael Fiore PDF and its ability to help you get your ex back using tiny text messages sent from your cell phone. Please click here my website ...

fuck buddies Fucking Contact - Why? Reasons to use Fucking Contacts are many. Many want a Fuck Buddy today instead of a relationship. In recent decades it has become more common that people prefer "lighter" relationships particularly serious. Fucking Contacts has become socially acceptable. Find a Fuck Contact today! Here on fuckbuddy69 there are thousands of members around the world and everyone is looking for the same thing! All days of the week, day or night, there are thousands of horny Fucking Contacts online looking for a Fuck Buddy! Horny girls and guys who want to get their wettest dreams come true. It does not matter what you're looking for within sex, here is all the categories! It's 100% free to join fuckbuddy69 fuck dating and you decide if you want to upgrade to the GOLD or VIP. For more info, visit my website ...

Posted by khare on 9.19.14 at 10:31

how to buy the pdf Ex Factor Guide: Brad Browning Reveals His Unusual And Weirdly Effective Relationship Repair System For Quickly Turning The Tables And Getting Your Ex Back After A Breakup... Written for consumers by a consumer, this fan site includes a fun and informative Ex Factor review, ebook FAQ, and PDF download guide that provides an insider's look at the program and answers frequently asked questions about Brad Browning's unique and highly popular ex back guide. For more info, visit our site ...

Qualifying Loan Payment With our Payment Finder, you can see what, and how much it will cost you for that House too. Please visit my site for more information ...

Posted by khare on 9.24.14 at 2:22

Very good blog post, it is so important to read it fully with passion for better understanding of the posted topic, the comments is also so nice to read, thanks for sharing such informational content. Modifikasi Motor rumah minimalis Gambar Mobilcara diet sehat alami

Posted by Tas Wanita on 9.26.14 at 23:09

flip pdf pages

Posted by soupe on 9.30.14 at 2:44

one of the positive things I have ever done is to visit the website / blog it. I am very impressed with your article writings. Good luck friend Penyakit Akut

Posted by ariherbal on 9.30.14 at 17:25

Glaucoma is a type of eye disease that is very difficult to cure, but here we provide natural herbal remedies of glaucoma <a href="">obat glaukoma</a> | <a href="">obat radang otak</a>

Posted by indriyani on 9.30.14 at 17:50

Glaucoma is a type of eye disease that is very difficult to cure, but here we provide natural herbal remedies of glaucoma obat glaukoma

Posted by indriyani on 9.30.14 at 17:52 Panic Away Program: Barry McDonagh Reveals His Weirdly Effective Approach To Quickly And Easily Stop Panic Attacks And End Anxiety Without Medications Or Crazy Therapy Sessions... Written for consumers by a consumer, this fan site includes a fun and informative Panic Away review, ebook FAQ, and PDF download guide that provides an insider's look at the program and answers frequently asked questions about Barry McDonagh's unique and highly popular panic attack treatment guide. Please visit website ...

Posted by khare on 10.1.14 at 10:48

By reading knowledge will increase. It is one of the best article to read. Thank you for the treat information. <a href="">Pengobatan Kista Rahim</a> | <a href="">Obat Vertigo</a>

Posted by ariherbal on 10.1.14 at 20:29

Thank you for the treat information Pengobatan Kista Rahim Obat Vertigo

Posted by ariherbal on 10.1.14 at 20:31

Thank you for sharing information, may be useful for all readers Obat herbal kanker usus besar

Posted by Humaira on 10.1.14 at 21:27

Through the website, let us increase the quality of science and education. with news and information that is accurate and useful we offer to the community. and we provide information to you about Obat Untuk Penyakit Kanker Lidah

Posted by pinkydanpeppa on 10.1.14 at 21:29

how to make yourself irresistible to a guy What Men Secretly Want: James Bauer Reveals His Highly Sought After "Respect Principle" For Making A Man Want You, Commit To You, And See You As The One Woman He Can't Live Without. Written for consumers by a consumer, this site includes a fun and informative What Men Secretly Want review and buyers guide that provides an insider's look at the program and answers frequently asked questions about James Bauer's unique and highly popular guide to understanding men. What Men Secretly Want teaches you principles and techniques to keep a guy interested, make him fall in love, and get him to commit both physically and emotionally. Explore our fan site to learn everything you need to know about the program so you can decide if What Men Secretly Want is the right choice for you before you buy it. visit website ...

Posted by khare on 10.3.14 at 3:24

all the information here is very helpful and very helpful for me, also visit our website

ciri ciri penyakit obat batuk obat tbc

Posted by yudistira on 10.3.14 at 21:19

Improve your Worlds of Warcraft Game Play Here Players often find unique tricks to improve performance, stability, or security, ultimately leading to a more enjoyable game experience. Unfortunately, it can be difficult to effectively communicate such tips to the WoW community. The purpose of this thread is to provide a home for such information that may otherwise be lost in the void. This compilation is the successor to the previous User Tips and Tricks thread. Thanks much!! Better Worlds of Warcraft Game Play. For more info, visit website ... Hook Your Ex: Steve Pratt Reveals His Ingenious Little Trick For Quickly Getting Your Ex To Want You Back After A Breakup... Written for consumers by a consumer, this fan site includes a fun and informative Hook Your Ex review, ebook FAQ, and PDF download guide that provides an insider's look at the program and answers frequently asked questions about Steve Pratt's unique and highly popular relationship guide. For more info, visit my website ...

Posted by khare on 10.10.14 at 4:22

I don't precisely hail from the middle of the humanities. I'm an economist, with a specialization in health and economic development. <a href="" rel="follow">Android TV Box</a>

Posted by Deborah Philip on 10.14.14 at 3:10

Really appreciate this wonderful post that you have provided for us.Great site and a great topic as well i really get amazed to read this. Buy SEO Packages buy quality backlinks manual directory submissionpagerank backlink buy backlinks Buy High pagerank backlinks Social Bookmark Services Buy Link Wheel Service directory submission pr5 backlinks High Pagerank Backlinks

Posted by Maddaysingh098 on 10.15.14 at 1:16

how to kiss a girl Get The Girls Like You now! Why not start now to get all that you want from the opposite sex. Get the girl you like, or meet a new one! Why wait for someone you can't stand get her before you? For more info, visit my website ... Beauty Food Bible: Tracy Patterson Reveals How To "Eat Your Way Beautiful", Achieve Flawless Skin, And Take Years Off Your Appearance Without Chemicals, Drugs, Or Injections... Written for consumers by a consumer, this fan site includes a fun and informative Beauty Food Bible review, ebook FAQ, and PDF download guide that provides an insider's look at the program and answers frequently asked questions about Tracy Patterson's unique and highly popular natural beauty and nutrition guide. Please visit website ...

Posted by khare on 10.17.14 at 20:14

about the author Diabetes Miracle Cure: Dr. Robert Evans And Paul Carlyle Reveal A Weirdly Effective, Science-Backed "BAT Activation Technique" For Curing Diabetes Naturally In As Little As 3 Weeks... Written for consumers by a consumer, this fan site includes a fun and informative Diabetes Miracle review, ebook FAQ, and PDF download guide that provides an insider's look at the program and answers frequently asked questions about Dr. Robert Evans and Paul Carlyle's unique and highly popular diabetes treatment guide. Please click here site ...

Posted by khare on 10.19.14 at 20:28



New User/Guest?

Find it Here:
search type:
search in:

« Previous   |   Next »
« Most Recent Post
« Permalink
Print Email RSS feed

Photo Galleries
2 3 4 5 6 7 8
9 10 11 12 13 14 15
16 17 18 19 20 21 22
23 24 25 26 27 28 29
Copyright © 2014 by The Valley Advocate.