Wednesday, August 21, 2013 • 10:19 AM Comments (36)

Johnny Football, The Flutie Effect, and the Myth of College Athletics Amateurism

posted by Pete Redington

If you haven't yet read it, check out the outstanding Sports On Earth article "Johnny Football vs. The NCAA," which just about perfectly addresses the complexity, hypocrisy, and utter buffoonery of big time (business) college sports and its "non-professional" status, as well as the current controversy regarding reigning Heisman Trophy winner Johnny "Football" Manziel, star quarterback for Texas A & M University, who allegedly sold his autographs for money ("The horror!"), which, as Patrick Hruby notes, is just the latest "example of the ridiculous nature of amateurism."

Manziel, like all top name athletes at all big-time university programs, is technically just a student-athlete playing football. But, due to his high-profile success, he effectively "works for the school," writes Hruby, "performing marketing, campus entertainment and alumni outreach duties."

This is largely due to the infamous "Flutie Effect," whereby the success of a university's athletic team (usually football, or men's basketball), especially one featuring a media-grabbing story (see "Situationist Philosopher Guy Debord and the Unbelievable True Story of Manti Te'o's Fake Dead Girlfriend," Free Sport, 1/18/13) charismatic individual (such as Natick, Mass-born and bred Doug Flutie, the legendary Boston College quarterback who won the Heisman Trophy in 1984, led his team to a victory in the Cotton Bowl - back when the Cotton Bowl was one of only four major bowls - all of them played on New Year's Day, and completed possibly the most famous ("Hail Mary") pass in the history of college football, forever since known as the "Miracle in Miami") leads to greater interest and thus revenue for the university.

(Current UMass Athletic Director John McCutcheon was at BC during the Flutie Era, and has referenced their football success in regards to the UMass program making the jump to the upper Football Bowl Subdivision - formerly known as Division 1-A football, and the correlating financial commitments.)

"Here's how it works," Hruby explains.

"In 1984, Boston College defeated Miami on a last-second, game-winning touchdown pass thrown by Eagles quarterback Doug Flutie. Over the next two years, applications to the former school went up by 30 percent. Academics and marketers alike call this "the Flutie Effect" -- that is, the admissions uptick that accompanies high-profile athletic success, like Georgetown's applications increasing by 45 percent between 1983 and 1986, the same period in which Patrick Ewing led the school's basketball team to an NCAA title and national prominence. Numerous academic papers have found that winning big-time football and basketball teams spur increased donor and alumni giving, too, the same way a slick Apple marketing campaign spurs sales of the latest iPhone. When the St. Mary's (Calif.) men's basketball team reached the Sweet 16 of the 2010 NCAA tournament, a study found that the total publicity value to the school was roughly $9.3 million. Last year, Texas A&M estimated that quarterback Johnny Manziel's Heisman Trophy win earned the school $37 million in media exposure."

Now $37 mil in advertising sounds like a pretty good return on a couple years of college tuition* (big-time stars rarely play through their four years of eligibiltiy before heading to the NFL) to me.

Hruby breaks down that figure by quoting from ESPN's Rick Reilly:

"A study by Joyce Julius & Associates found that, last season alone, Manziel was worth $37 million in "media exposure" (free advertising) for the Aggies. By December, the school bookstore sold out all 2,500 replica jerseys it had. There's a guy on eBay who says he's sold 625 "Johnny Football" T-shirts at $20 each. The Collegiate Licensing Company figures that winning a Heisman increases your sales and royalties by 27.5 percent over five years."

Texas A & M is currently spending $450 million to renovate its home stadium, Kyle Field (aka "The Home of the Twelth Man"). But it will likely never be known as The House That Johnny Football Built, because Manziel may have sold a few autographs for a few bucks, thus violated the sacred amateur nature of non-professional, big business college football.

* Conditional, of course, as Hruby dutifully notes.

Comments (36)
Post a Comment

Braden, she began out herself up in the last years of her way of lifestyle to details her amazing journey, from a endowed youngsters in the divided The southern portion of to a culture as one of the most important white-colored control of the public privileges action. data entry work from home

Posted by JHFHGVJH on 8.3.14 at 1:52

The pitching wedge healthy salad ($8.50) was outstanding, a slice of sharp, cool iceberg almost as big as your go, lovely with a wonderful frothy Roquefort putting on a costume. Read More At this website

Posted by JHFHGVJH on 8.3.14 at 7:47

Nice information, valuable and excellent design, as share good stuff with good ideas and concepts, lots of great information and inspiration, both of which I need, thanks to offer such a helpful information here. click for more

Posted by JHFHGVJH on 8.3.14 at 23:05

Appreciate your taking this possiblity to mention this, I’m strongly regarding it and I benefit from studying this subject. If at all, as you gain data, please update this site with new information. overview of Buttonwood Real Estate LLC

Posted by JHFHGVJH on 8.4.14 at 5:32

FAQ, and PDF download guide that provides an insider's look at the program and answers frequently asked questions about Michael Fiore's unique and highly popular texting guide. dentist Brooklyn

Posted by JHFHGVJH on 8.6.14 at 0:40

Truth About Cellulite review and buyers guide that provides an insider's look at the program and answers frequently asked questions about Joey Atlas' unique and highly popular cellulite removal system. a more authentic experience

Posted by JHFHGVJH on 8.6.14 at 5:24

I used to be very pleased to find this internet-site.I wanted to many thanks for your time and efforts just for this amazing go through! ! I absolutely taking pleasure in each small amount of it and I have you ever added to look into new stuff you blog post. with a focus on East Village

Posted by JHFHGVJH on 8.7.14 at 0:00

Do you mind if I quote a couple of your posts as long as I provide credit and sources back to your blog? My blog is in the exact same niche as yours and my users would really benefit from some of the information you provide here. Please let me know if this ok with you. company profile

Posted by JHFHGVJH on 8.7.14 at 22:49

Trying to say much obliged won't simply be sufficient, for the fantasti c clarity in your written work. I will right away snatch your rss channel to stay educated of any upgrades. http://www.nber.org/people/christian_broda

Posted by JHFHGVJH on 8.8.14 at 4:45

Often it is the amazing deficiency of way of lifestyle of someone near that provides this home; and then the regularity of medical center trips and memorials gradually begins to select up amount, like a drumbeat in the forests. http://www.allvoices.com/contributed-news/16973540-determining-whether-or-not-to-use-a-staffing-agency-like-brian-torchins-hcrc

Posted by hjhjkh on 8.9.14 at 3:53

The pitching wedge healthy salad ($8.50) was outstanding, a slice of sharp, cool iceberg almost as big as your go, lovely with a wonderful frothy Roquefort putting on a costume. FreedomPop

Posted by JHFHGVJH on 8.11.14 at 6:33

I am commenting to let you know what a terrific experience my daughter enjoyed reading through your web page. She noticed a wide variety of pieces, with the inclusion of what it is like to have an awesome helping style to have the rest without hassle grasp some grueling matters. the first free cell phone plan

Posted by JHFHGVJH on 8.11.14 at 23:36

It seems that many company and personal marketing emails are going on digitally these days. It is often much easier to write a quick email or send a brief written text than to get in touch with someone on the cellphone. www.lulu.com

Posted by hjhjkh on 8.13.14 at 4:52

Over the years, we have helped grow lots of company activities and have helped numerous companies increase their display participation. AHR Expo, Xylem and FieldAware are among a few of our customers in the HVACR industry. Nonton Film Gratis

Posted by JHFHGVJH on 8.13.14 at 23:55

There is a lot of eliteism going on in football these days. The guys who have talent are pushed away by everyone else who feels the need to highlight their inefficientcies. Invicta watch bands

Posted by Camouflage recliner on 8.14.14 at 11:12

New York, where the exotic bride receives a less than enthusiastic welcome by the groom’s family, the elite of Gilded Age elite, and then to Paris, where her race and position are more readily accepted. park office

Posted by JHFHGVJH on 8.15.14 at 0:36

The House That Johnny Football Built, because Manziel may have sold a few autographs for a few bucks, thus violated the sacred amateur nature of non-professional, big business college football. Going Here

Posted by JHFHGVJH on 8.15.14 at 8:21

Over the years, we have helped grow lots of company activities and have helped numerous companies increase their display participation. AHR Expo, Xylem and FieldAware are among a few of our customers in the HVACR industry. www.crunchbase.com

Posted by JHFHGVJH on 8.16.14 at 0:23

Clymer teaches Spanish and humanities at Eastern Mennonite University, Harrisonburg, Va., including leading students on semester-long cross-cultural programs to Guatemala and Mexico. for a career in analysis

Posted by JHFHGVJH on 8.16.14 at 4:58

His industrial soundscapes can be heard on the soundtracks of Resident Evil: Extinction, the Saw franchise and in the opening theme of FX's American Horror Story. Porter Stansberry

Posted by JHFHGVJH on 8.17.14 at 0:17
Posted by JHFHGVJH on 8.17.14 at 7:15

it's really nice and meanful. it's really cool blog. Linking is very useful thing.you have really helped lots of people who visit blog and provide them usefull information. Judi Bola Online Terpercaya

Posted by JHFHGVJH on 8.17.14 at 23:19

This is the long run and everyone needs to do their part with power preservation,” said Robichaud. “There is no purpose why a plumbing professional can’t cause the way and set the example. www.businessinsider.com

Posted by hjhjkh on 8.18.14 at 0:43

I called a great post, very very cool and awesome. Really I love the Ingredients till its making.

https://www.rebelmouse.com/michaelfioresecretsurveyreview
Posted by aqibarif74123 on 8.18.14 at 10:55

it's really nice and meanful. it's really cool blog. Linking is very useful thing.you have really helped lots of people who visit blog and provide them usefull information. next article

Posted by JHFHGVJH on 8.18.14 at 23:26

The pitching wedge healthy salad ($8.50) was outstanding, a slice of sharp, cool iceberg almost as big as your go, lovely with a wonderful frothy Roquefort putting on.

hop over to these guys
Posted by lassehuovinen on 8.19.14 at 5:11

Very helpful, a well written piece. Looking forward for more such posts from you. Marc Sparks photos online

Posted by JHFHGVJH on 8.19.14 at 7:47

This post is just purely wonderful. It is glamorous and Filled With glistering information. circus acrobat training

Posted by JHFHGVJH on 8.22.14 at 0:46

In fact, lack of way of life is an everpresent reality; it way of life at the boundary of self and ego and explains our way of life. old school new body system

Posted by hjhjkh on 9.1.14 at 5:34

Best Mac Pc Computer Repair Services Jupiter like the way you explained the difficult topic with such details. This is something I have been exploring about for a long time and you really provided all details of this topic.It is a very nice post.

Posted by Best Mac Pc Computer Repair Services Jupiter on 9.6.14 at 5:39

Best Mac Pc Computer Repair Services Jupiter like the way you explained the difficult topic with such details. This is something I have been exploring about for a long time and you really provided all details of this topic.It is a very nice post.

Posted by Best Mac Pc Computer Repair Services Jupiter on 9.6.14 at 5:39

Although the Chicago area naturally receives the most attention, it's honestly an exciting time to be doing business as a plumbing company in southern Illinois. my link

Posted by JHFHGVJH on 9.15.14 at 7:29
Hey I'm Marnie! I'm a realtor, and have been for more than 30 years. Right now I'm running my own brokerage, Bennett Property Shop Realty. I'm just here to have fun, and hopefully find some funny pictures to laugh at haha. Cellex-C
Posted by Cellex-C on 9.16.14 at 1:56

Really good stuff here, I'm truly amazed at everything you've said here. You're beyond a talented blogger and you've got a unique set of skills when it comes to writing. Boston College is a great program, so it's good for them that they have somewhat of a national spotlight. melbourne fl website design

Posted by Marcus Mindy on 9.16.14 at 12:08


This is great! It really shows me where to expand my blog. I think that sometime in the future I might try to write a book to go along with my blog, but we will see.Good post with useful tips
new year messages 2015.Celebrate this new year withhappy new year wishes 2015
how to . Enjoy your new year eve.

Posted by Piano on 9.18.14 at 8:05

Because the fact of the matter is that all day long, your potential clients are saying, writing, and sharing things like,Don’t those phrases just sound like hundred dollar bills sweeping against each other…being counted and handed over to you? backlinks

Posted by gegastar on 9.19.14 at 20:51
Comment:

Name:

Password:

New User/Guest?

Find it Here:
keyword:
search type:
search in:

« Previous   |   Next »
« Most Recent Post
« Permalink
Print Email RSS feed

Copyright © 2014 by The Valley Advocate.