Thursday, March 25, 2010 • 12:00 AM Comments (5)

Health Care Reform (Quote/Unquote)

posted by Sarah Werthan Buttenwieser

As I watched and listened to the process I was being told to view as “history being made” and the “defining moment of Obama’s presidency,” I found myself feeling hollow. I am not so much a skeptic—pinky-swear—yet, yet the reform part of health care reform, in my mind, meant something different. I think reform meant that the assumption of responsibility for health care moved from each of us to all of us. Far as I could tell, that did not happen (Thom Hartmann on his radio show called changes made that mean more people will receive health care “nice.” He added, “There’s no single player, there’s not even a public option. It isn’t reform.”)

The abortion for health care equation frustrated me from the start. Stephanie Poggi, executive director of the National Network of Abortion Funds issued a statement after the vote. She writes: “As a nation, we demanded that health care reform address the inherent inequality and unfairness in our existing system. But with the stroke of his pen, President Obama expanded the Hyde Amendment's guarantee of inequality and unfairness. By singling out abortion care, Congress and our President have betrayed their obligation to protect the interests of all people living in this country, not only those who already have every advantage.”

There are so many reasons the changes made represent a marked improvement from what exists. Reform, perhaps, seems a stretch. So much of the status quo has not changed (the Dow did not plummet; insurance companies must have felt they won—and even if you dispute the changes as a win for them, no major loss at the very least). Still, the Teddy Kennedy camp saw victory. Representative Patrick J. Kennedy (D-R.I.), the late Senator’s youngest son, visited his father’s gravesite on Monday morning and left a hand-written note that read: "Dad, the unfinished business is done." It is?

**

Meantime, as numerous news stories reported, during the weekend of voting and this week, threats against Democratic members of Congress have been made repeatedly, from racial and homophobic taunting outside on Capitol Hill by protestors to health care reform to off-color remarks on the House floor (“baby-killer,” implications that fellow representatives should die in order to stop these changes from happening) to phone and Internet threats, rocks through windows and on. Bob Herbert wrote about the need for zero tolerance for this kind of behavior in his column this week, entitled An Absence of Class: “It is 2010, which means it is way past time for decent Americans to rise up against this kind of garbage, to fight it aggressively wherever it appears. And it is time for every American of good will to hold the Republican Party accountable for its role in tolerating, shielding and encouraging foul, mean-spirited and bigoted behavior in its ranks and among its strongest supporters.”

You’d almost think, from the vitriol seen, that something like reform has actually happened.

**

I see in myself that when a much longed for change seems potentially within reach, rather than become more patient, I become more impatient, because I let myself want it. I think that could describe my personal experience of the Obama administration to a ‘T.” I thought reform would look different and better. I thought I’d be riding high. I am in my own muck, not cursing, not threatening and certainly not feeling transcendent.

A friend who supports Jill Stein’s bid for Governor in Massachusetts keeps urging me to support her, too, pointing out that so many of her stands more closely match my own views (single payer, for starters). I can’t say I am dazzled by Governor Deval Patrick’s performance thus far. And yet, I’m pretty sure I’m a team player, on the Democratic team that cannot deliver upon my expectations or my hopes. There’s a long view buried somewhere in here, perhaps. There’s at least a pragmatist view that change can be agitated for from outside the system but will only be codified from within. I’m probably going to be somewhat cranky, a disgruntled Democrat. And as for health care reform, I’m going to keep the air quotes—for now.

Comments (5)
Post a Comment

Sarah, your thoughts echo my own concerns that the "business" is partially unfinished, but that nagging concern over half measures doesn't begin to scare me like the backlash does. Herbert's piece and Rachel Maddow's coverage over the past few days have been spot on in showing us what is going on outside this very rarified community, and reminding us that we need to act to stem this tide! Keep up the excellent blogging! I enjoy following you!

Posted by Jennifer on 3.25.10 at 10:34

Sarah, if you're looking for a more progressive Democrat to support in the governor's race, what about Grace Ross?

http://www2.graceross.org/?q=Issues

Posted by Mo Turner on 3.25.10 at 17:06

Sarah, you are on target here! But we also have to be cognizant that radical changes can happen through increments over time. Ideally, no one should be getting rich from the misfortunes of others, and for this reason a for-profit healthcare is a recipe for disaster that it is. On the other hand, it is difficult to convince the disciples of the free market religion that it is anything other than a theory, and a debunked one at that. So, the way I see this "reform", is that this is just the beginning of a long and arduous battle. And for all of us left-leaning equity seekers, the mission is far from accomplished.

You can see more of my take on healthcare in the US on my blog, Healthcare, etc., here http://evimedgroup.blogspot.com

Posted by Marya on 3.25.10 at 18:56

Radical change would not be this status quo special interest subsidizing health care "reform". Have you seen the taxpayer revenues and government regulations that were promised to persuade the endorsement of health insurers, care providers, and phamaceuticals? No government run by political elitists (of either persuasion) can ever be trusted to legislate or administrate for the interests of the people over their interests in political authority. Equity for the people will never be sustained better than by liberating us from force and fraud, whether peddled by big government, big corporations, or their cozy alliances. Fortunately, in America, we still have State's sovereignty, equal Judicial authority, and free civil Elections.

Free market economics has sustained affordable, available, and competitive insurance for all other needs (auto, homeowner, life, etc.), except heavily government regulated and subsidized health insurance. And, what, if anything, does a health INSURANCE entitlement do to contain rising health CARE costs, which this "reform" bill does not address adequately?

A truly radical change would be to end the government getting richer and more powerful from the misfortunes of it's constituents. Did you know, the IRS is hiring nearly 17,000 new agents to enforce this new health care "reform" bill? If there are no new taxes, and the bill is really deficit neutral, why such an expansion of federal government, during the worst economic recession since the Great Depression?

Posted by Ronald Keith on 3.26.10 at 23:58

1. Are air quotes like air kisses?

2. The good side of the despicable Republican behavior is that it might continue to remind the Democrats that they can't rest for a second that they need to constantly fight back.

3. Healthcare went through. Yes, it is not how we want it but if it hadn't snuck in, Hyde Amendment and all, we'd be looking forward to a Republican president so soon again. So hopefully it will evolve into something better and that poor Republicans will think again about who is looking after them.

4. This is still a difficult time to get anything done. There is a recession. The housing market has not recovered. There are two foreign battles going on still. To get this through under these conditions is a triumph, however small.

Posted by Emily Marbach on 3.31.10 at 10:56
Comment:

Name:

Password:

New User/Guest?

Find it Here:
keyword:
search type:
search in:

« Previous   |   Next »
« Most Recent Post
« Permalink
Print Email RSS feed

Archives
MARCH 2010
S M T W T F S
  1 2 3 4 5 6
7 8 9 10 11 12 13
14 15 16 17 18 19 20
21 22 23 24 25 26 27
28 29 30 31      
March Rains
Opening the Box
Who Knew?
Privilege/Perspective
Links
Copyright © 2013 by The Valley Advocate.