News

How Black is Obama?

Does Barack Obama's success help or hinder the struggle for racial equality?

Comments (2)
Thursday, February 21, 2008

How can racism still be a problem if so many white Americans are willing to support Sen. Barack Obama for president? This rhetorical question worries some analysts, who warn that Obama's prominence, ironically, could set back the struggle for racial equality. They argue that his trans-racial appeal would convince many that the country has "transcended race," making them less supportive of efforts to redress slavery's legacy. Obama's intentions have little to do with this effect. His trailblazing campaign is part of a racial dynamic set in motion long before his white Kansan mother met his black Kenyan father. Their union produced a son whose fame has triggered a substantive conversation about race and culture in a nation where it is long overdue.

Race as a concept emerged contemporaneously with the first burst of European capitalist expansion in the 18th century. Scientific texts like Carolus Linnaeus' 1786 work Systema Naturea had begun classifying humans according to new racial taxonomy, and African people usually wound up on the bottom rung of humanity's ladder.

These scientific "proofs" joined theological treatises and philosophical musings to implant white supremacy as European conventional wisdom. This mindset helps explain how the Founding Fathers rationalized (and condoned) the existence of racial slavery in a nation ostensibly based on freedom and liberty. American slavery added wrinkles to the reigning conventional wisdom. In our version of human bondage, only Africans and their progeny were eligible—or "enslaveable."

A brutal slave system and rigid racial hierarchy transformed enslaved multi-ethnic Africans into African-Americans—a distinctive variation in the African diaspora.

Just one drop of African blood conferred blackness, and that helped ensure a ready supply of enslaved workers. Children of white slave owners and enslaved women helped pad the workforces of many plantations and account for the wide range of complexions in the black community today. The notion of an inherent "blackness," then, is a concept of commerce, coined to justify European plunder. (Similarly, hundreds of European ethnicities were conflated into a confining notion of "whiteness.")

Despite Obama's hybrid racial pedigree, he is "black" by the one-drop tradition. Unlike most black Americans, however, his history is not framed by generations of racial subordination. This distinction is significant. Because Obama's ancestral narrative lacks slavery, his self-image likely lacks the wounds from that history. Although he has a more varied source of identity, Obama identifies as an African-American and became conversant with the racial choreography of American culture. White Americans likely sense the lack of racial grievance and respond gratefully. This gratitude helps explains why Obama mania has swept the nation. He openly embraces aspects of his blackness as well, which allows whites to see him as an authentic repository of their historical guilt from which he can then absolve them.

In his 2006 book The Audacity of Hope, Obama notes "race fatigue" and writes that "white guilt has largely exhausted itself in America" as "even the most fair-minded of whites... tend to push back against suggestions of racial victimization and race-based claims based on the history of racial discrimination in this country." Some critics argue that Obama intentionally accommodates this race fatigue. "Obama is playing to the perverse racial politics of the post-civil rights era," writes Paul Street in the webzine ZNet, "wherein the leading architects of policy and opinion have declared 'race' as a barrier to black advancement."

This is a complicated tale. When detractors of Obama note he lacks an ancestry framed by chattel slavery, they make a valid point. What's more, white Americans are likely to view Obama's rise as a sign that racism is at bay. However, they also may grow to understand that Obama's success charts the potential for many African-Americans for whom the legacy of slavery has lingered too long.

 

Comments (2)
Post a Comment
Great article! I also wrote about Obama and the one-drop legacy, so I find your comments in that regard especially helpful. "Racial choreography" is also an excellent term for capturing the performed quality of racial identities, which are often like scripted role-playing (white people in particular often fail to realize the racial roles they've been encouraged to play). However, I have a quibble about this comment: "Because Obama's ancestral narrative lacks slavery, his self-image likely lacks the wounds from that history." These wounds are real, but they don't only come about as a result of one's own ancestors having been slaves. The lingering, pernicious legacy of slavery has more widespread effects; they impinge on black consciousness from MANY sources, on a daily basis. I think your focus on a direct ancestral lineage for these effects overlooks their insidious creep into so many features of contemporary society. Thus, your comment discounts the effects of the legacy of slavery, and of the subsequent Reconstruction and American Apartheid eras, on all African Americans, including descendants of later immigrants.
Posted by macon d on 5.21.08 at 6:28
Oops, sorry, here's another try at that messed-up link.
Posted by macon d on 5.21.08 at 6:30
Comment:

Name:

Password:

New User/Guest?

Find it Here:
keyword:
search type:
search in:

« Previous   |   Next »
Print Email RSS feed

Pro-Choice Choices
Imperium Watch: Let's Get Back to Making Things
We let our manufacturing sector dry up at our peril.
American Catechism
Andrew Bacevich's Washington Rules examines American orthodoxy and global warfare
Voters, Fasten Your Seatbelts
Jill Stein is finally in the gubernatorial debates--and she's got a lot to say.
Down to the Wire
Between the Lines: Changes
A note from the editor
Letters: What Do You Think?
This week: No Contest in D.A.'s Race; No Free Lunch; Greenfield Needs Facts, Not Opinion; Of BP and Vermont Yankee; and Letter About Letters
Success for Story's Bill for New Mothers