Going Public

Hilltown families fight to keep their local school

Comments (2)
Wednesday, April 09, 2014
Lynne Graves photo

Several years ago, faced with the imminent closing of their town’s elementary school, a group of Worthington families took a bold step: they formed their own independent school.

Now they’ve launched a major fundraising campaign, seeking to raise $300,000 over the coming weeks, to keep it open. That money would tide the school over for one more academic year—at which point, the families hope, a bill pending at the Statehouse would allow it to return to its earlier status as a public school.

In 2010, the Gateway Regional School District, citing budget pressures and a decreasing student population, decided to close three of the five elementary schools in the district. Under the plan, students in Blandford, Russell and Worthington would now be sent to one of the two remaining elementary schools, in Littleville and Chester.

Some Worthington residents, however, protested the idea of closing their local Russell H. Conwell School. “A big part of the problem we saw, living in a rural community as we do, was simply the amount of time our daughter was going to spend on a school bus,” John McDonald, a former Conwell parent, recalled recently.

But there were also broader reasons Worthington residents objected to the closing. In this town of 1,200, as in other small communities, the local elementary school serves a vital social role. “Whether it’s for the Easter egg hunt, the school play, the spaghetti supper … we don’t want to lose that focal point of the community,” McDonald said.


When the plan to close Conwell was first announced, a group of residents attempted to open a Horace Mann charter school—a sort of hybrid charter model, in which the budget and other matters must be approved by the local School Committee and the teachers’ union—in the Conwell building. After state officials turned down that proposal, the families considered turning the building into a hub for homeschoolers before eventually deciding to instead open a low-cost private school there, using the charter school proposal as a blueprint.

Now called the R.H. Conwell Community Education Center, the school educates about 26 students in kindergarten through sixth grade, as well as 12 to 15 children in a preschool program. It employs six full-time and two part-time educators, as well as a part-time director, according to McDonald, who now serves as president of Conwell’s board.

Conwell families pay a tuition of $1,500 per child, or a maximum of $3,000 per family—a miniscule amount compared to costs at other Valley private schools. “It’s not a tuition-based model at all,” McDonald said, noting that the school grants financial aid to families who need it, in keeping with its mission to provide an education to all children in Worthington.

Instead, the school relies heavily on fundraising events and individual contributions. In particular, McDonald said, it’s relied on support from musician Aaron Lewis, a founder of the rock group Staind, and his wife, Vanessa, who are Conwell parents. The couple started a foundation, called It Takes a Community, to financially support the school (it also supports other projects and programs in small New England communities), and Lewis has organized fundraising concerts and golf tournaments for Conwell as well.

In addition, McDonald said, the Lewis family has made personal donations to help the school cover its operating costs. While the Lewises will continue to hold fundraisers and offer support through the foundation, those ongoing direct contributions are no longer sustainable, said McDonald, who called the family’s support of the school “a debt we can never repay.”

The bulk—about 85 percent—of the $300,000 that the Conwell school hopes to raise would go to pay teacher salaries, McDonald said. The rest would help with other expenses, such as rent on its building, insurance and supplies. Given the difficulty of attracting grants from large foundations—“We’re talking about a couple dozen kids in a small town that no one’s ever heard of,” he said—the families expect most of that money to come from individual donors.

As of last week, the effort had raised about $20,000 and secured a $50,000 pledge from the It Takes a Community Foundation, according to McDonald. If the school falls short of its $300,000 goal, he said, it will consider scaled-down options, such as maintaining its classes for kindergartners through third graders only, or closing its elementary program but retaining its preschool and after-school childcare program, which is open to all kids in town, not just Conwell students. The school has set a fundraising deadline of mid-May, he added, so that teachers will have enough time to search for new jobs if necessary.


While a successful fundraising campaign would allow the independent Conwell Center to remain open through the 2014-15 school year, the long-term goal is for the school to become a public school once again.

A bill pending at the Statehouse, filed by state rep Steve Kulik (D-Worthington) and Sen. Ben Downing (D-Pittsfield), would allow Worthington to withdraw from the Gateway Regional School District. (Worthington could also withdraw with the unanimous approval of the six other communities that make up the regional district. However, Town Meetings in those towns have rejected that plan.)

If the bill passes, Worthington would then create an independent school district for grades kindergarten through six, and would seek an agreement with the Hampshire Regional School District that would allow middle and high schools students from the town to attend that district’s schools, with the town paying a set fee per child. While some discussions with Hampshire Regional officials have taken place, McDonald said, no agreement can be finalized until and unless Worthington is allowed to leave the Gateway district.

The bill has been approved in the House and now awaits a Senate vote. McDonald said he’s optimistic it will win final approval, allowing Conwell to reopen its doors in the fall of 2015 as the town’s public school.

McDonald estimates that about 80 percent of Worthington’s elementary school-aged population is enrolled at Conwell. His own daughter, who’s now in sixth grade, initially remained at Conwell before later moving to Gateway Regional Middle School—a one-hour bus ride away, he said—where she could receive special services she needed through an individual education plan. “That’s one of our limitations,” he noted. “By not really charging much for tuition, we can’t really provide special services.”

But, he added, Conwell offers important benefits to the entire town, bringing together residents and providing opportunities for them to volunteer or otherwise demonstrate community support. “People come to the fundraiser, whether they have kids or not. People come to the school play,” McDonald said. “The elementary school really serves as one of the focal points of the community.”•

Comments (2)
Post a Comment

This is a school i greatly believe in. I do not have children in this school or live in the town.But am very much behind this as well as many other things in worthington. I went to worthington in 2009 to build a home for a deserving soldier and his wife. I left my heart here while falling in love with the town.. So have had to return many times. I try to volunteer or do other jobs here. To stay close to the community and its residents. This school is truly a great school. I too buy from each fundraiser to help. I sell as many of the items to my family,friends and clients. everyone is very involved in helping out the school on my end.But we still need many more on board please help! You don't need a child to give just a belief in the concept and its teachings.

Posted by Catherine Salisbury on 4.13.14 at 18:20

Over the past month, Conwell has made amazing progress, and while I still can't go there and am stuck on a bus for an hour to Gateway, because of John McDonald, I still have connections with most of the kids there, and am pretty good friends with a few. I don't mind the bus ride all that much (my awesome bus driver has the radio set on the best country station around and practically blows our eardrums out with it). The only thing I really don't like is having to wake up at 6:15 every morning while most of my friends wake up 2 hours later. Back on topic, Worthington has officially left the Gateway district!!! I look up to four people for making it all happen: Aaron and Vanessa Lewis, for saving the school at the last minute before it would be gone forever; my mom, Gretchen Eliason, for defying the Gateway school comitte's years of lying that started with little things, like some numbers getting mixed up, but progressed to Worthington being allowed to leave the district and even uncovering some legal trouble for the superintendent for holding a "secret school comitte meeting" in which she was not originally invited to, but she showed up anyway; and most of all, my dad, John McDonald, who stayed up late at night for months figuring this whole thing out, and eventually making it all worthwhile. Let's hear it for them!

Posted by Aine McDonald on 5.2.14 at 18:20



New User/Guest?

Find it Here:
search type:
search in:

« Previous   |   Next »
Print Email RSS feed

Better Later?
More joining the ranks in favor of a later start time for high schools
Between the Lines: Riding the Brand
Martha Coakley and Charlie Baker are more afraid to lose than inspired to win.
More Than A Coal Job
A veteran of the Mount Tom energy plant begins again.
From Our Readers
In Satoshi We Trust?
Outside the Cage
How solid is the case for organic and cage-free egg production?
Between the Lines: Practically Organic
Does the organic farming movement make perfect the enemy of good?
Scene Here: The Kitchen Garden Farm