Guest Column: A Valley Divided

Comments (5)
Wednesday, July 31, 2013

As a cultural anthropologist working on environmental, health and socioeconomic equity issues in Springfield, I have observed for too long that the racially- and class-stratified “tofu curtain” has divided the Pioneer Valley into an affluent, mostly white north and a marginalized but diversified south. Nowhere is this truer than for the people of Springfield and Holyoke. A significant structural factor has been the lack of affordable, accessible and sufficient regional public transit. This gap in our regional infrastructure has profoundly negative environmental consequences, contributes to global warming, negatively impacts public health, reinforces racial apartheid and creates enormous economic hardship for the poorest among us.

Eighty-seven percent of the black and 81 percent of the Latino populations in the Valley live in these two towns. This fact has led the University of Michigan to conclude that our region is one of the most racially segregated in the nation. Lack of public mass transportation to all places is a leading factor in sustaining racial apartheid and economic inequity in the Valley.

Springfield and Holyoke residents are the poorest in the region. Child poverty rates are 42 percent in Springfield and, in Holyoke, 48.7 percent, nearly 4 times the statewide rate of 12.8 percent—a problem made worse by the fact that much of the regional economic activity occurs outside the cities, in places unreachable except by car. If efficient bus route service is extended to all sectors of the region, the people of these towns can participate on a more equal footing in our economy.

This is also true of education. While the University of Massachusetts has made some efforts to address the lack of access for these two cities, local economic interests have consistently stonewalled efforts to connect them to the flagship campus of the Commonwealth. Lack of direct and affordable transportation has meant that many in these towns do not consider UMass when choosing a college. That makes public transportation an educational equity issue.

For those who travel from these cities to the wealthy communities of Northampton or Amherst, the cost is extraordinarily high. While I, as a Northampton resident, can take a bus that comes every 20 minutes and costs a little over a dollarto get to UMass, folk from Springfield must take a circuitous, time-consuming (over two hours) route or shell out $16 to $19 dollars for a much quicker round trip on a private bus line. People from Holyoke must spend $8 to $10 dollars for the same trip. This makes commuting north unfairly burdensome for the poor.

There is also an environmental issue here, because PVTA sends the new “green” buses to Northampton/Amherst and doesn’t put them in Springfield. Fifty-three percent of pollution emissions in Springfield come from vehicles. Both cities have very high asthma rates (20 percent in Springfield, 24 percent in Holyoke), a problem made worse by car pollution. By adding new bus routes—and making them comprehensive and consistent—we can reduce critical air pollution problems and positively impact public health in these cities.

By making intercity transportation affordable, frequent and reliable, we can address serious socioeconomic inequity and public health issues, and reduce the racial polarization of the region.•

Comments (5)
Post a Comment

Yet, it seems that even the Mayor of Holyoke is more concerned with Ward 7 and the other NIMBY's to even give a crap about these startling facts... It's a heck of a lot easier to fight ghosts and amorphous entities like Walmart, Casinos, or Global Capitalism than it is to face the hard facts of everyday poverty and racial segregation...

Posted by JoseAngel on 8.6.13 at 6:41

JoseAngel- If there was a "like" button here.....I would "click" it

Posted by Enron411 on 8.6.13 at 20:18

Thomas Taffee- Do you have sources/links that show where you get your statistics from for this particular piece?

Posted by Enron411 on 8.6.13 at 20:24

"Racial Apartheid"?

Are we really going to compare this situation to the level of oppression of ethnic groups in South Africa or Israel, where people were/are legally prohibited from movement outside of certain tightly gaurded zones?

Minorities have always suffered the most from economic marginalization in our society. But remember there are plenty of poor white folks without proper access to public transportation as well.

I'd say this problem is ultimately rooted in class and not race. For example, if you have the means and you are a minority you can buy a house or rent an apartment in the upper valley.

Posted by Jay James on 8.8.13 at 14:00

Let us not be diverted by silly discourse over whether clean accessible affordable transportation between the upper and lower valley is 1)more or less important than keeping predatory Walmart out of Holyoke and/or 2)racism or classism plays a bigger role in the disparities that exist. The intersection of race and class should be clear to all and worker rights issues intersect as well. We need to address the issue of clearly inequitable transportation services without delay or dichotomous thinking - for the reasons stated in this well articulated plea for moving forward together - on buses and for each other.

Posted by Amy Bookbinder on 8.9.13 at 8:41



New User/Guest?

Find it Here:
search type:
search in:

« Previous   |   Next »
Print Email RSS feed

From Our Readers
Baker: More of the Same; Props to Rohmann; Props to Rohmann
Between the Lines: A Gun Owner’s Resentment
Why make it expensive and difficult for law-abiding residents to possess firearms?
Sorry, Nixon
If the impeachment of our 37th president showed that the system works, what does Obama’s continued political survival say about it?
The Zipcar Is Here
Car sharing takes hold in the Valley.
Under the Microscope
Did ex-WSU president Evan Dobelle use university resources to support an identity as well as a lifestyle?
From Our Readers
Casino Opposition “Selfish”; Cut Foreign Aid, Not Our Military
Between the Lines: Deval’s Capital Management
He can rehab his office, but what about his legacy?
From Snowden to the Pentagon Papers
Can student interest in civics be rekindled?