Letters: What Do You Think?

This week: Iran: “War Is Failure”; Brown Health Policy Bad for Seniors; and Monitoring Homelessness

Comments (1)
Thursday, November 01, 2012

Iran: “War Is Failure”

War is no answer to the present conflict between the U.S. and Iran. While I was glad to hear in the presidential debate talk about peaceful resolution of the conflict, I’m concerned that our feckless Congress and some of its chickenhawk members could undermine diplomacy. I hope Senators Kerry and Brown will speak out on the Senate floor in support of diplomacy to prevent war and a nuclear-armed Iran and oppose any legislation that puts roadblocks in the way of diplomacy.

Talking to the Iranians does not mean that they are the good guys. But raining death down on their innocent citizens does not mean that we are. War is failure. War is disaster. War is death.

Robert Lipton


Brown Health Policy Bad for Seniors

According to the 2010 Census, 3,863 people aged 65 and older live in Northampton, and every one of them should be deeply concerned about Republican Scott Brown’s health care policy. The centerpiece of Brown’s health care policy is working to repeal the Affordable Care Act, the federal health care reform law known as Obamacare.

National health care advocacy organization Community Catalyst Action Fund released a new analysis finding that, if the Affordable Care Act (“Obamacare”) is repealed, senior citizens in Northampton and across Massachusetts will be saddled with higher costs and fewer benefits.

Obamacare, as it is called, lowers seniors’ Medicare premiums and out-of-pocket costs by an estimated $500 per year. This means that, if Republican Scott Brown gets his way and repeals Obamacare, seniors’ Medicare costs will go up about $5,000 over the next decade.

Obamacare also fills in the so-called “donut hole” in prescription drug coverage for seniors. Between January and August of this year, 31,000 Massachusetts residents hit the “donut hole.” Obamacare saved those Medicare beneficiaries an average of over $600 per person. This means that, if Republican Scott Brown gets his way and repeals Obamacare, seniors’ prescription drug costs will go up dramatically.

Also, during the first eight months of 2012, over 500,000 Medicare beneficiaries across Massachusetts took advantage of no-cost preventive services thanks to Obamacare. If Republican Scott Brown gets his way and repeals ObamaCare, seniors will lose these no-cost preventive services.

Policy decisions made in Washington, D.C. have a real and direct impact on the residents of Northampton. The health care policy that Republican Scott Brown is advocating would have a decidedly harmful impact on Northampton’s seniors.


Mathew Helman


Monitoring Homelessness

Thank you for your article “No Place to Live” (October 18, 2012), drawing attention to family homelessness and recent state policy changes responding to this urgent issue.

The Western Massachusetts Network to End Homelessness, an organization that includes over 100 partners and offers broad-based coordination and collaboration to reduce homelessness across the four western counties, provided the central vehicle in the region for discussion and debate over the Commonwealth’s new family shelter regulations.

After multiple meetings over many weeks [that included housing advocates, shelter and housing providers and numerous state agency representatives, the Network arrived at a position on the State’s proposed regulatory changes that can be found on our website at

In short, the Network commends the Patrick-Murray administration for its underlying mission to meet homelessness with housing instead of shelter [i.e. in shelters and motels] and applauds the Commonwealth for its increased investment in prevention, re-housing and affordable housing programs. At the same time, the Network is concerned about the unintended consequences that may flow from the regulatory changes, putting families in harm’s way. To better address these concerns, the Network has established an oversight committee that will monitor the impact of these regulations in Western Massachusetts. We will relay our findings and recommendations to state officials, and continue to work together towards our shared goal of keeping families safe and housed. 

Pamela Schwartz
Director Western Massachusetts Network to End Homelessness

Comments (1)
Post a Comment

This article or letter titled "Brown Health Policy Bad for Seniors" is pure deceit from some Warren for Senator front group run by political consultants who are being paid to scare us seniors.

The Community Catalyst report cited by the paid consultants is very deceptive and both Catalyst and Warren are poor advocates for us seniors. In its analysis, Community Catalyst purposely leaves out 200,000-300,000 Massachusetts seniors -- disproportionately the poorest of us Massachusetts seniors -- on Part C Medicare health plans. These are the seniors who are already getting the global-payment/coordinated-care-type plans glorified by Obama's Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act (PPACA) advocates and the Massachusetts politicians that recently gave us our new price-fixing legislation.

PPACA of course is the law that is cutting over $700 billion from what should be spent on Medicare over the next 10 years -- or kept in the Medicare Part A trust fund if not needed. PPACA is taking the $700 billion from Medicare and spending it instead on insurance for non-seniors (see the Medicare actuary, all annual reports since 2010).

As for the so-called drug savings touted by the Warren front group and Warrent herself, in Massachusetts they are almost non-existent. None of the Democrat's statistics take into account what Massachusetts Prescription Advantage or MassHealth pays for seniors on Medicare. The Assistant HHS Director of Planning has said the effects of these state program are not factored into the calculations he did and that Catalyst and these paid politcal operatives (apparently paid by Warren) are using in their Mediscare propaganda.

Posted by Dennis Byron on 10.31.12 at 6:08



New User/Guest?

Find it Here:
search type:
search in:

« Previous   |   Next »
Print Email RSS feed

Flight Fight
The FAA’s evolving drone policy is sure to induce outrage.
From Our Readers
Casinos Need Problem Gamblers; A Better World with Ryan
Don Berwick may have lost to Martha Coakley in the Democratic primary, but not without winning hearts and minds in Western Mass.
Between the Lines: Martha Coakley Remade
The Democrats’ choice for governor still needs to find her star power.
From Our Readers
Gun License Mathematics; The Gun Tribe; Torturers Go Unpunished
UMass works to turn academic research into useful products—and profit.
Between the Lines: The Birth of Ajax Montoya
Debut novelist Joe Gannon brings his memorable detective to life.
Thanks, Anonymous
A private UMass donation sends us on a fruitless quest.