Wellness: Motherhelp

A state commission on post-partum depression organizes resources for moms in crisis.

Comments (17)
Friday, March 02, 2012

Typically, bills that aim to make public policy changes ride a slow track through the Massachusetts Legislature; it's not unusual for proponents to refile their bills over multiple legislative sessions, only to see the proposal not come up for a vote until it's been through several iterations—if ever.

That made it all the more impressive when state Rep. Ellen Story (D-Amherst) saw a bill she'd filed early in 2009 to help women with post-partum depression pass in just one session.

Among other things, the new law creates a commission made up of state officials, medical professionals and others involved in the field to advise the Department of Public Health on ways to improve services for new mothers. Appointees include Liz Friedman, a Northampton mother who herself has experienced post-partum crisis and who now works as program director at MotherWoman, the Amherst-based nonprofit that was instrumental in the bill's passage.

Various studies place the percentage of women who experience post-partum depression at 10 to 15 percent. A 2008 study by the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention surveyed women in 17 states (Massachusetts not among them), asking if they'd experienced symptoms of depression after giving birth; researchers found rates ranging from 11.7 percent (in Maine) to 20.4 percent (in New Mexico), with certain groups—teen moms, women with lower levels of education, poor women, women who've experienced stress or trauma—at highest risk.

In December, the Commission on Post-Partum Depression held its first meeting, under Story, who serves as its co-chair. To Friedman, it's one more sign of the progress that's been made in addressing post-partum mental-health issues. "In six years, we've seen a complete transformation in the way this region has been addressing this issue," she said. "The legislation bumps everything up on the priority list."


The Post-Partum Depression bill was passed by the state Legislature and then signed into law in the summer of 2010. In addition to establishing the commission, the bill calls for the DPH to improve public education and training for health care professionals in recognizing and treating post-partum mental health issues. The law also requires health insurers to submit to the state annual reports on their efforts to address post-partum depression.

The final version of the bill did not include one earlier provision that had proved controversial: a mandate requiring universal screening of all new mothers for post-partum depression. Backers of that provision argued that it would ensure that no women fell through the cracks, and would remove any potential stigma felt by individual women who'd been "singled out" for screening.

But some critics contended that universal screening amounted to a violation of privacy. Others—most notably, Northampton's Freedom Center, a nonprofit that's critical of the mainstream mental health establishment—worried that mandated screening could lead to overdiagnosis of mental health disorders, and overprescription of psychiatric drugs.

"There is also a concern that having more people being officially diagnosed with 'postpartum depression' could become a self-fulfilling prophecy," the Freedom Center wrote in an open letter to MotherWoman during the debate on the bill. "If a person is having a hard time and is told that it is a disease of some sort, they are less likely to understand their experience as something natural or something that will pass."

In the end, Story removed the mandatory screening provision from the bill. "While we are really happy to see these screenings are no longer going to be mandated, we are still concerned that there is some danger in the way that this bill is likely to increase postpartum depression diagnoses. By increasing the number of people who have these diagnoses, there is an increased risk of getting mothers involved in a profit-driven psychiatric system that is not always set up to serve them," the Freedom Center's Lee Hurter told the Advocate at the time. "We fear that the increase in the diagnoses will take our communities away from having a bigger understanding of some of the social, economic, and political factors that play into having a difficult time in the post-partum period."


To Friedman, it's regrettable that the universal screening provision became a divisive issue, given that MotherWoman shares many of the concerns expressed by the Freedom Center. MotherWoman's work includes activism to improve public policy and social supports for families, for instance.

And, Friedman said, she understands concerns about the potential risks of rushing women toward diagnoses and drugs. "Those are legitimate concerns, and those concerns exist whether we screen or not," she said.

Friedman continues to believe in the crucial importance of screening all new mothers, rather than screening only those whom doctors suspect might be struggling—a practice that runs the risk of "profiling" women who might seem distressed while overlooking others who are suffering but don't show it as obviously. "Some of us can put on a good show," she said. "And others of us, quite frankly, are always a mess."

It's important, Friedman continued, for healthcare professionals who work with new mothers to receive adequate training on post-partum mental issues; right now, obstetrics/gynecology residents, for instance, get minimal training in mental health issues. One goal of the PPD commission is to ensure that health professionals on all levels are educated about risk factors for post-partum issues, their symptoms and effective treatment. (Those risk factors and symptoms can vary broadly; indeed, while the legislation refers specifically to post-partum depression, Friedman favors language that covers the full spectrum of emotional problems mothers might face, referring, for instance, to "perinatal complications.")

It's also important that there's a system in place that allows easy referrals to treatment and other supports for women who need it. "Providers want to do the right thing," Friedman said, but they need sufficient training and access to resources to help their patients.

Treatment, Friedman added, does not necessarily include prescription drugs. "We put a lot of eggs in that basket. We think diagnosis and medication is the answer," she said. That makes it all the more important that health professionals are well versed in what medications are or aren't appropriate for treating new mothers, as well as alternative means of treatment. Those other kinds of treatments can be very helpful, in place of or in addition to medication; Friedman, for instance, turned to acupuncture when she was experiencing post-partum crisis.

Many women turn to support groups such as the ones run by MotherWoman in the four western counties. (For a complete list, go to www.motherwoman.org/groups.) The groups, which are free and open to all new mothers, are led by trained facilitators who guide the meetings while emphasizing the peer-led nature of the group. "We say, 'We're winging it as mothers, too,'" Friedman said.

For some women, the groups are enough; for others, they're part of a larger treatment plan. "What we've seen is, these support groups are really transforming lives," Friedman said. "It bursts the isolation bubble of new motherhood, which is such a source of crisis."

In this setting, mothers are reminded that they're not alone with the complex emotions they might be experiencing, be they depression, intrusive thoughts, anxiety, disappointment. "Women can speak here about the things they can't elsewhere," Friedman said. "Perinatal adjustment is intense for everyone."

And when women struggle without help, there can be long-term effects for the entire family. Studies show that when a parent is depressed, children are more likely to experience problems with social, emotional and cognitive development.

But there is good news, too, Friedman said: "We know women with care and treatment recover well." The commission she sits on is determined to make sure more women who need that treatment receive it.

Comments (17)
Post a Comment

Thank you to Mo Turner for writing a strong article on Perinatal Emotional Complications like depression and anxiety in a way that truly educates the community and connects all of us with the work that is being done on the state-wide level.

Please contact us at MotherWoman is you are a mother experiencing emotional challenges connected to pregnancy and postpartum or if you have input for the MA Postpartum Depression Commission. You can reach me directly at liz@motherwoman.org.

Thank you.

Posted by Liz Friedman on 2.29.12 at 16:58

Shameless connect here don’t skip the Fab Five as they present “The Technological City Hall” at AHR Jan 28 at 1:00 p.m. agen bola online

Posted by hjhjkh on 7.10.14 at 1:08

This blog post really grabbed my attention. With that said I am going to subscribe. Therefore I will get more updates on what you have to say. Please keep writing as I want to learn more. go to next page

Posted by Ted on 8.3.14 at 21:37

I am writing. Thank you for giving me another point of view on this difficult situation. peliculas gratis

Posted by jams123 on 8.12.14 at 3:47

The following tips will assist you as you get started in the lucrative field of web marketing. rumah dijual di surabaya

Posted by jams123 on 8.12.14 at 6:25

Very informative blog post.Really looking forward to read more. Keep writing.
Enjoyed every bit of your blog.Really looking forward to read more. Really Cool. https://archive.org/details/TaoOfBadassReview

Posted by Xertaui77 on 8.31.14 at 10:45

You should comment on the competition comparison of the blog. You can highlight it's mind boggling. http://acnenomorereviewd.weebly.com/

Posted by Xertaui77 on 9.1.14 at 11:44

We really thank you for your wonderful article. You have created your
page, I believe really helped us a lot. Recommended Reading

Posted by abel671 on 10.10.14 at 21:05

I am so much excited after reading your blog. Your blog is very much
innovative and much helpful for any industry as well as for person. Recommended Reading

Posted by abel671 on 10.10.14 at 21:06

this was a really quality post. In theory I'd like to write like this too - taking time and real effort to make a good article... but what can I say... I procrastinate a lot and never seem to get something done. Recommended Reading

Posted by abel671 on 10.10.14 at 21:07

You actually make it appear so easy with your performance but I find this affair to be actually something which I think I would never comprehend. Recommended Reading

Posted by abel671 on 10.11.14 at 0:02

Wow, it is so interesting post. Very useful information. I really like this post. I will bookmark and share to everyone. Thanks for posting a great article. Recommended Reading

Posted by abel671 on 10.11.14 at 0:04

I really learn a lot of good things in this blog and I am sharing it with my friends who are searching similar type of information from a lot of days. Hope so this post will be very helpful for everyone. Recommended Reading

Posted by abel671 on 10.11.14 at 0:05

I cannot WAIT to read more of this. I mean, you just know so much about this. So much of it I've never even thought of. You sure did put a new twist on something that I've heard so much about. Recommended Reading

Posted by abel671 on 10.12.14 at 0:19

A doctor can bury his mistakes but an architect can only advise his clients to plant vines. recommended reading

Posted by abel671 on 10.12.14 at 0:20

this was a really top quality post. In theory Let me write like this particular too - taking time and real effort to make a good article... but so what can I say... I procrastinate a great deal and never manage to get something accomplished. How apple pay works with passbook?

Posted by steve7876 on 10.12.14 at 11:20

This one helped me for a thesis which I am writing. Thank you for giving me another point of view on this difficult situation.

billige smartphones
Posted by jams123 on 10.15.14 at 6:19



New User/Guest?

Find it Here:
search type:
search in:

« Previous   |   Next »
Print Email RSS feed

Wellness: Fading Scars
Breast cancer gene research has come far in the last 20 years, but work remains.
Smart Apps vs. Obamacare
Comparatively cheap diagnostic tools may allow patients to self-collect health data more assiduously than a team of ICU nurses.
Rest isn’t always the answer to chronic pain.
Paradise Regained
Valley author Suzanne Strempek Shea’s new book looks at a mother’s remarkable response to tragedy
Wellness: Cord Blood Banking
Why new parents need to educate themselves about cord blood banking
Wellness: Gut Check
The new science of good bacteria
The Burden of Caring
A Valley journalist delves into the challenges faced by family caregivers.
Refusing vaccination puts others at risk.